Controversial Christmas Song About 1980s Mall Santa Sparks Outrage
By Kelly Robbins Culture Correspondent DECEMBER 15, 2024 — MINNEAPOLIS, MN A new Christmas song has stirred a nationwide controversy after it was revealed to be based on the true story of Malcolm Edward Mantiss, a mall Santa arrested in the 1980s for predatory behavior. The song, “Santa Got Caught,” written and performed by indie artist Nick Frost, recounts Mantiss’s actions and subsequent disgrace, turning a decades-old scandal into an unlikely holiday tune. Critics have called the song tone-deaf, with many accusing Frost of trivializing a serious issue by framing it in the context of festive cheer. The Scandal of Malcolm Mantiss Malcolm Edward Mantiss (photographed) was a beloved figure in the 1980s, serving as the Santa Claus at the Winter Haven Mall in Cleveland, Ohio. His career came to a shocking end in 1987 when he was arrested following accusations of inappropriate conduct with teenage mall employees. Mantiss pleaded guilty to several charges and served five years...